Pinkney Island_1.jpg

Reasonable Alternatives

Proposed Reasonable Alternatives Overview

Proposed Reasonable Alternatives Overview

The Preliminary Range of Alternatives and the Proposed Reasonable Alternatives were presented to the public at a Public Information Meeting on September 19, 2019. Based on input received from the public and agencies, the Proposed Reasonable Alternatives were revised to include the following:

  • Coordination with US Fish and Wildlife Service regarding the six Proposed Reasonable Alternatives (RA1-6) resulted in a revision to Alternative 4 that moved the proposed interchange on Pinckney Island closer to the existing US 278 Corridor. This revision resulted in a new alternative, Alternative 4A.

  • Alternative 5 and Alternative 6 utilize the existing Power Line Easement to relocate US 278 to a new 6-through-lane (travel lane) section from the end of the new Skull Creek Bridges through Jenkins Island. Based on input from the utility companies, these two alternatives were revised to run south of the existing power line easement across Jenkins Island. These revisions resulted in two new alternatives, Alternative 5A and Alternative 6A.

  • All of the Proposed Reasonable Alternatives, except for Alternative 5, were revised to provide more efficient ingress/egress to properties on Hog Island. In addition, the revised Hog Island access allows for an improved maintenance of traffic during construction. Figure 5-2 illustrates the ingress/egress developed for Alternative 2 which is representative of all the Proposed Reasonable Alternatives, except for Alternative 5.

Based on the public input and the revisions explained above, the six (6) reasonable alternatives were revised to nine (9) Proposed Reasonable Alternatives shown below, with the new alternatives denoted with “A” in the name following the number.

R1.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 1 (RA1)

Build new eastbound Mackay Creek bridge south of the existing bridge

Recondition and widen existing westbound Mackay Creek bridge

Recondition and possibly widen Skull Creek bridges

Use existing alignment as much as possible

R2.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 2 (RA2)

Build a new bridge to the north of existing westbound Mackay Creek bridge

Recondition existing westbound Mackay Creek bridge and convert to eastbound traffic

Use newly constructed bridge for westbound traffic over Mackay Creek

Recondition and possibly widen Skull Creek bridges

R3.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 3 (RA3)

Build 2 new eastbound bridges south of the existing alignments, one over Mackay Creek and one over Skull Creek

Recondition and widen westbound Mackay Creek Bridge

Recondition existing Skull Creek Bridges and convert to westbound traffic only


R4.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 4 (RA4)

Replace all 4 existing bridges with one new bridge immediately south of the existing alignment

Build a new access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Use existing alignment east of the new bridges

Remove existing bridges

4A.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 4A (RA4A)

Same as RA4 but revised based on Public and Agency Feedback, See above

Replace all 4 existing bridges with one new bridge immediately south of the existing alignment

Build a new access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Use existing alignment east of the new bridges

Remove existing bridges

R5.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 5 (RA5)

Build 2 new eastbound bridges just south of the existing

Recondition westbound bridges and widen in place

Improve access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Utilize the existing transmission line easement running from Jenkins Island through Spanish Wells Road



5A.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 5A (RA5A)

Same as RA5, but revised based on Public and Agency Feedback, See above

Build 2 new eastbound bridges just south of the existing

Recondition westbound bridges and widen in place

Improve access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Utilizing property adjacent to, but just south of, the existing transmission line easement for US 278 running from Jenkins Island through Spanish Wells Road

Remove existing bridges

R6.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 6 (RA6)

Replace all 4 existing bridges with one new bridge just south of the existing US 278 alignment

Build a new access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Utilize the existing transmission line easement running from Jenkins Island through Spanish Wells Road

Remove existing bridges

6A.PNG

Reasonable Alternative 6A (RA6A)

Same as RA6, but revised based on Public and Agency Feedback, See above

Replace all 4 existing bridges with one new bridge just south of the existing US 278 alignment

Build a new access to the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge and CC Haigh Jr. Boat Ramp

Utilizing property adjacent to, but just south of, the existing transmission line easement for US 278 running from Jenkins Island through Spanish Wells Road

Remove existing bridges

Preliminary Range of Alternatives

Preliminary Range of Alternatives

Preliminary Range of Alternatives

Incorporating feedback from the community along with known constraints and challenges, the engineering team developed 17 alternatives called the “Preliminary Range of Alternatives” shown on this map. These 17 alternatives were systematically evaluated using the criteria in the Alternatives Evaluation Criteria Matrix to determine the Reasonable Alternatives. These criteria include the projected number of properties that may be impacted, as well as potential impacts to neighborhoods, protected lands and wetlands. Potential impacts were quantified using Geographical Information Systems (GIS) and the best available data from federal, state and local government sources. Those preliminary alternatives that moved forward as the recommended preferred alternatives are shown in pale yellow on the map to the right.